Close Menu

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from FooBar about art, design and business.

    What's Hot

    Misso ignores warnings and leaves the blue city in the dark before the holiday blackout

    May 27, 2025

    “Green” waste accumulates as solar panels and wind turbines contaminate landfills

    May 27, 2025

    No, climate change is not after the UK's mosquito fear

    May 27, 2025
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
    Weather Guru Academy
    Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram Pinterest
    • Home
    • Weather
    • Climate
    • Weather News
    • Forecasts
    • Storms
    Subscribe
    Weather Guru Academy
    Home»Climate»'Fossil fuels are a legal consumer good': Baltimore climate lawsuit dismissed
    Climate

    'Fossil fuels are a legal consumer good': Baltimore climate lawsuit dismissed

    cne4hBy cne4hJuly 17, 2024No Comments4 Mins Read
    Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Share
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email Copy Link

    Shell gas station

    A Maryland judge last week dismissed the city of Baltimore's lawsuit against energy companies, inflicting huge damage to the nationally coordinated climate litigation movement. [emphasis, links added]

    The ruling firmly rejected the bedrock legal theory behind the lawsuit, explaining: National laws cannot be used to drive national energy policies and address global phenomena such as climate change:

    “The federal structure of the Constitution does not allow the application of state law to claims made by Baltimore. … The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that state law cannot be used to resolve claims seeking compensation for injuries caused by out-of-state pollution (sources). (bold)

    The failure of a lawsuit filed by Baltimore in 2018 marked another blow to a litigation campaign backed by a national network of activist groups, academics, paid media and foundations of billionaires like Rockefeller.

    It could also be a comforting moment for officials in neighboring Baltimore County, ahead of a vote to hire Sher Edling, the law firm representing the city of Baltimore and dozens of others. Prescient lawmakers on both sides of the aisle expressed concerns, vetoing a 2022 lawsuit of their own.

    Judge: Lawsuit is a 'backdoor' to solve global emissions problem

    To support her point of view, Baltimore City Circuit Court Judge Videtta Brown cited a ruling by the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals that affirmed the dismissal of New York City's original 2021 climate lawsuit, A ruling in January significantly limited the scope of the Delaware lawsuit.

    A deceptive lawsuit does nothing to change Baltimore's fundamental attempt to regulate global energy production, and Judge Brown pointed out that this “back door” attempt is to solve the so-called harm caused by global climate change, which should be dealt with through legislative means.:

    “Baltimore's explanation is that it is simply seeking to resolve and hold defendants accountable for a deceptive misinformation campaign, which is Just a way to get in something through the back door that they can't get in through the front door. […]

    “Congress never intended for individual states to handle complaints based on global pollution.” (Bold emphasis)

    Judge Brown, appointed by former Democratic Gov. Martin O'Malley, also pointedly pointed out a fundamental problem with these nuisance lawsuits: The production, use and consumption of traditional energy is completely legal and necessary for modern life.

    “Defendant's product itself is not considered dangerous. Fossil fuels are legal consumer products subject to guidance and regulation by the EPA. Liability is not assumed even if the normal functioning of the product is dangerous. (bold)

    Experts stress importance of ruling, look forward to Supreme Court

    Experts on both sides commented on the importance of dismissal, i.e. The ruling intensifies calls for the U.S. Supreme Court to review the merits of the lawsuit.

    Judge Brown’s ruling neatly questions the logic of the Hawaii Supreme Court’s refusal to dismiss Honolulu’s climate lawsuit, which is currently being appealed to the Supreme Court:

    “This case exceeds the limits of Maryland law. Again, the bottom line is Baltimore, just like New York (If the truth be told Honolulu), intend to hold [Defendants] easy under [Maryland] law, The impact of global emissions over the past hundreds of years.“(emphasize)

    Noting the differences between the decisions of the Hawaii Supreme Court, Delaware state courts, and now Maryland state courts, wall street journal The editorial board believes the Honolulu petition should be approved, writes “The increasing conflict in the lower courts was an important reason for the justices to consider this case.”

    Even Michael Gerrard, a professor at Columbia Law School’s Sabin Center and a long-time leading supporter of climate litigation, described the ruling as a “setback” and acknowledged Baltimore court ruling raises risk of Supreme Court intervention:

    “There are cases going both ways on this. … This is primarily a state law issue and there is no uniform national outcome unless the U.S. Supreme Court steps in and puts an end to all cases.

    Bottom line: Dismiss Baltimore's climate lawsuit outright, Baltimore Circuit Judge Videtta Brown correctly saw through activists’ attempts to regulate U.S. climate policy through the back door.

    With no victory in sight, this latest defeat could further chill other attempts at the litigation elsewhere around the country, including in places like Michigan.

    Popular photo on Unsplash by adrian susec

    Read more about EID Climate

    related

    Source link

    Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr Email
    Previous ArticleWeather forecast for Wednesday, July 17, 2024
    Next Article Denver will have a nice cooldown on Wednesday
    cne4h
    • Website

    Related Posts

    Climate

    Misso ignores warnings and leaves the blue city in the dark before the holiday blackout

    By cne4hMay 27, 2025
    Climate

    “Green” waste accumulates as solar panels and wind turbines contaminate landfills

    By cne4hMay 27, 2025
    Climate

    No, climate change is not after the UK's mosquito fear

    By cne4hMay 27, 2025
    Climate

    We need your help to cover this summer’s Hurricane » Yale’s Climate Connection

    By cne4hMay 27, 2025
    Climate

    A free store to help hurricane survivors in western North Carolina solar energy » Yale's climate connection

    By cne4hMay 27, 2025
    Climate

    How climate shocks cause the prevalence of youth anxiety

    By cne4hMay 26, 2025
    Add A Comment
    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Don't Miss

    Misso ignores warnings and leaves the blue city in the dark before the holiday blackout

    By cne4hMay 27, 2025

    New Orleans fell into darkness when grid operators in the area cut off reduced use…

    “Green” waste accumulates as solar panels and wind turbines contaminate landfills

    May 27, 2025

    No, climate change is not after the UK's mosquito fear

    May 27, 2025

    We need your help to cover this summer’s Hurricane » Yale’s Climate Connection

    May 27, 2025
    Demo
    Top Posts

    Misso ignores warnings and leaves the blue city in the dark before the holiday blackout

    May 27, 2025

    Syracuse Watch | News, Weather, Sports, Breaking News

    July 14, 2024

    The weather service says Beryl's remnants spawned four Indiana tornadoes, including an EF-3 | News

    July 14, 2024

    PM Modi seeks blessings of Jyotirmat and Dwarka Peesh Shankaracharyas on Anant Ambani-Radhika businessman wedding

    July 14, 2024
    Stay In Touch
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Pinterest
    • Instagram
    • YouTube
    • Vimeo

    Subscribe to Updates

    Get the latest creative news from SmartMag about art & design.

    Ads
    adster1
    Legal Pages
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy
    Our Picks

    Misso ignores warnings and leaves the blue city in the dark before the holiday blackout

    May 27, 2025

    “Green” waste accumulates as solar panels and wind turbines contaminate landfills

    May 27, 2025

    No, climate change is not after the UK's mosquito fear

    May 27, 2025
    Most Popular

    Misso ignores warnings and leaves the blue city in the dark before the holiday blackout

    May 27, 2025

    Syracuse Watch | News, Weather, Sports, Breaking News

    July 14, 2024

    The weather service says Beryl's remnants spawned four Indiana tornadoes, including an EF-3 | News

    July 14, 2024
    Ads
    ads2

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.